Hillcrest lists 11 Italian restaurants and pizza shops in 92103, led by the cash-only New York slices at Bronx Pizza and the white-tablecloth Italian menu at Arrivederci Ristorante on University Avenue. Parma Cucina Italiana anchors the fresh pasta side.
811 W Washington St, San Diego, CA 92103
+1 619-298-6464
Verified111 Washington St, San Diego, CA 92103
+1 619-291-3341
Verified3603 Fourth Ave, San Diego, CA 92103
+1 619-255-4200
Verified3845 Fourth Ave, San Diego, CA 92103
+1 619-299-6282
Verified3850 Fifth Ave, San Diego, CA 92103
+1 619-543-0049
Verified741 W Washington St, San Diego, CA 92103
+1 619-295-6000
Verified1040 University Ave B101, San Diego, CA 92103
+1 619-310-5256
Verified3401 First Ave., San Diego, CA 92103
+1 619-230-5283
Verified4033 Goldfinch St, San Diego, CA 92103
+1 619-600-5311
Verified127 University Ave, San Diego, CA 92103
+1 619-505-2627
Verified1280 University Ave, San Diego, CA 92103
+1 619-297-7272
VerifiedBronx Pizza is the most-reviewed pizza shop in Hillcrest and one of the most-reviewed in all of San Diego. The format is simple — cash-only, New York-style slices served from a window counter on Washington Street, no table service, no delivery apps, no frills. The thin crust, foldable slices, and late-night hours have made it the neighborhood's default post-bar stop for decades.
Sisters Pizza runs a slightly different format with full pies and a more traditional sit-down setting. Fiori's Pizza handles the smaller-operation end with a focused menu, and Tavola Nostra Pizzeria e Cucina brings a Neapolitan style with blistered crust and San Marzano sauce. For more pizza options east of the neighborhood, Tribute Pizza in North Park serves Neapolitan pies with natural wines.
Arrivederci Ristorante is the longest-running traditional Italian restaurant in Hillcrest, with white tablecloths, a full wine list, and a menu that covers pasta, veal, chicken, and seafood in classic preparations. The University Avenue location has been a neighborhood anchor for date nights and family dinners for years.
Parma Cucina Italiana leans into fresh pasta and regional Italian dishes with a slightly more modern presentation. The Red Door runs a seasonal Italian menu in a more intimate setting, and Cardellino offers Italian-inflected dishes with a wine-bar atmosphere. Mia Trattoria rounds out the full-service options with a neighborhood trattoria format.
Yes. Bronx Pizza is cash only — no cards, no mobile payment, no exceptions. The policy has been in place since the shop opened on Washington Street, and regulars know to hit the ATM before heading over. The cash-only format keeps the line moving and the prices low, and it is part of what gives the shop its no-frills New York slice shop identity.
The rest of Hillcrest's Italian and pizza restaurants accept cards. Sisters Pizza, Tavola Nostra, and every full-service Italian restaurant in the neighborhood run standard payment systems. Bronx Pizza is the only holdout, and it is intentional.
Several Hillcrest pizza spots offer delivery through third-party apps or their own ordering systems. Sisters Pizza handles delivery for full pies, and Tavola Nostra runs delivery alongside its dine-in Neapolitan menu. Bronx Pizza does not deliver — the cash-only, window-counter format is dine-in and takeout only.
For broader delivery coverage across the 92103 ZIP, most of the major delivery platforms service the Hillcrest area from restaurants in neighboring North Park and downtown San Diego as well. The density of pizza options within walking distance, though, makes pickup the faster option for most Hillcrest residents.
Parma Cucina Italiana runs a fresh pasta program with house-made noodles served alongside traditional Italian sauces and proteins. The pappardelle and ravioli are the dishes regulars single out. Arrivederci Ristorante serves fresh pasta as part of its broader Italian menu, with classics like fettuccine Alfredo and linguine alle vongole.
The Red Door rotates its pasta offerings seasonally, and Cardellino blends Italian pasta traditions with a wine-forward dining concept. Farmer's Bottega also runs an Italian-leaning farm-to-table menu that includes house-made pasta, bridging the American and Italian categories.
San Diego Lineup is a neighborhood-first civic business directory covering 40 communities across San Diego County. From restaurants, bars, and coffee shops to salons, contractors, doctors, and local services — Hillcrest’s businesses are organized by neighborhood with verified details, ratings, and direct contact information. Explore all San Diego communities →
Get listed on San Diego Lineup — email us at [email protected] and we’ll get you added.
New photos, updated hours, or a better description — email us at [email protected] and we’ll take care of it.