Pacific Beach's 3 seafood listings cover grilled fish tacos and poke bowls at Pacific Beach Fish Shop on Mission Boulevard, a full restaurant-and-retail fish market at The Fishery on Mission Bay Drive, and market-fresh catches at Nico's Fish Market in 92109.
745 Emerald St, San Diego, CA 92109
+1 858-352-6432
Verified5040 Cass St, San Diego, CA 92109
+1 858-272-9985
Verified1775 Garnet Ave, San Diego, CA 92109
+1 858-483-4746
VerifiedPacific Beach Fish Shop is the most reviewed seafood restaurant in the neighborhood, serving grilled and fried fish tacos, poke bowls, and seafood plates in a casual beer-garden setting on Mission Boulevard. The menu leans toward the Baja and Southern California approach to seafood — fresh, simple preparations with local and imported catches — and the outdoor seating fills early on summer evenings.
The Fishery operates as both a seafood restaurant and a retail fish market on Mission Bay Drive, which means the fish served in the dining room is the same product sold in the case — a transparency that most seafood restaurants in San Diego do not offer. Nico's Fish Market adds another market-and-restaurant combination, giving Pacific Beach three dedicated seafood operations within a small footprint.
Pacific Beach Fish Shop is a casual seafood restaurant on Mission Boulevard known for its fish tacos, poke bowls, and grilled catch plates served in a beer-garden format with communal picnic tables. The operation built its reputation on a straightforward formula — fresh fish, simple preparations, and a cold beer on the side — and the Pacific Beach location is the original shop that launched the Fish Shop brand.
The restaurant serves lunch and dinner with a menu that rotates based on what's available from the fish suppliers. The fish-taco format puts PB Fish Shop in direct competition with Oscar's Mexican Seafood on the Mexican side of the Pacific Beach dining scene, and locals regularly debate which shop serves the better version — a rivalry that benefits anyone who likes fish tacos in 92109.
The Fishery is both. The Mission Bay Drive location operates a full retail fish market alongside a sit-down restaurant, and the two share the same supply chain — the fish in the market case is the same product that ends up on the restaurant plate. Customers can buy whole fish, fillets, and shellfish from the market side, or sit down and order a prepared meal from the restaurant menu.
The dual format is unusual for Pacific Beach and for San Diego in general — most seafood restaurants source separately from their retail operations. The Fishery's approach means the menu reflects what actually came off the boats, and the fish quality stays consistent because the retail market holds the same product to the same standard. For a similar market-and-restaurant experience, Point Loma Seafoods in Point Loma runs the most recognized version of this format in San Diego.
The Fishery on Mission Bay Drive operates a full retail fish market where you can buy whole fish, fillets, shellfish, and specialty seafood by the pound. The market side runs independently from the restaurant — you don't need to dine in to buy from the case — and the selection reflects what is currently available from local and regional fisheries.
Nico's Fish Market adds a second retail fish option with a similar market-and-prepared-food combination. Between the two, Pacific Beach is better served for fresh fish retail than most San Diego beach neighborhoods, where dedicated fish markets are rare. For the largest selection in the area, Point Loma Seafoods sits about 10 minutes south and handles the highest volume of retail fish sales on the San Diego coast.
The best fish taco in Pacific Beach is a contested title between Pacific Beach Fish Shop and Oscar's Mexican Seafood. PB Fish Shop grills its fish and serves it on a corn tortilla with a beer-garden atmosphere on Mission Boulevard, while Oscar's on Turquoise Street batters and fries its fish in the Baja tradition with cabbage, crema, and a handmade tortilla.
The two restaurants represent different approaches to the same ingredient — grilled and clean at Fish Shop, battered and Baja-style at Oscar's — and most Pacific Beach locals have a preference but eat at both. Nico's Fish Market adds a third contender with its own fish-taco program, and The Taco Stand in La Jolla is a short drive north for anyone who wants to expand the comparison.
San Diego Lineup is a neighborhood-first civic business directory covering 40 communities across San Diego County. From restaurants, bars, and coffee shops to salons, contractors, doctors, and local services — Pacific Beach’s businesses are organized by neighborhood with verified details, ratings, and direct contact information. Explore all San Diego communities →
Get listed on San Diego Lineup — email us at [email protected] and we’ll get you added.
New photos, updated hours, or a better description — email us at [email protected] and we’ll take care of it.