Clayton's Coffee Shop is one of those rare places that has barely changed in decades — and that's exactly the point. This vintage diner on Orange Avenue has been serving classic American breakfasts, burgers, and pie since 1946, with counter seating, vinyl booths, and a working jukebox that give it genuine mid-century character. The menu is straightforward diner fare done well, and the coffee stays full. It's one of the most recognized breakfast spots on the island, and weekend mornings usually mean a wait — one that most regulars consider part of the experience.